Emma and I were invited, along with several other wine writers, to Trinity Hill last Friday to taste barrel samples from the 2012 vintage and to have a look at the about-to-be-released 2010 Homage. I keep looking at my photos from that day because it is hard to believe they were taken only a couple of days ago. Whilst here in Auckland we still have to shake off the cloak of winter (central heating on yesterday), we enjoyed the most perfect Hawke’s Bay sunshine.
Standing on top of Roy’s Hill, looking at the surrounding vineyards, it was hard (even for a townie like me) not to be envious of those who work in such stunning surroundings.
There’ll be a full write up of the wines posted next week when we relaunch the Independent Wine Monthly website
2011 Clearview Estate Vineyard Selection Chardonnay
When I wanted a big chardonnay to go with roast pork I remembered a sample box from Clearview Estate had arrived a few days previously. A chardonnay made in the true honker style was exactly what I fancied so texted home and asked Cee to unpack the box and put the bottle in the fridge.
When I opened the fridge door, the first thing I noticed was the flanged bottle, a la Dry River and the understated label front label declaring the wine to be 2011 Clearview Estate Vineyard Selection Chardonnay. A new wine? The back label states that a limited number of vines were selected to make the wine and so only 1100 bottles were produced.

Once opened, there was no whoosh of oak on the nose, a defining feature of Clearview chardonnays of old, just some bran biscuit and oatmeal with a hint of red apple and peach. And the palate? Taut and restrained with a clearly defined favour of lime, chalk and wet stones, lovely and silky yet with a definite line of acid running through. Biscuity, textural with amazing length. Could this be (gulp) an homage to Chablis.
But having promised to smack the next winemaker who releases a wine described as ‘Chablis-style’, it was a treat to see the understated back label .

I think this is an exciting evolution in NZ chardonnay. When I phoned Emma, she reminded me, rather smugly I thought, that Barry Riwai (who made the wine) had shown it to her a few weeks ago and that she had called to tell me how good it was. I was tempted to bop her on the snout instead . . .
25 Years of Wine Luncheon
I had to look at my itinerary twice to make sure I wasn’t dreaming. Usually I find hosted visits to wine regions means having a packed schedule with no respite from sun up to sun down. But the 12 noon pickup meant I could sleep in, do some writing and have plenty of time to get ready for the 25 Years of Wine Luncheon being held at Carrick Winery. What a luxury.
As it was, I woke early (still suffering from jet lag), caught up on all the gossip with John Saker over a couple of flat whites (him 2 x long blacks which seemed somehow fitting) so perhaps didn’t get quite as much done as I had hoped but never mind.
The idea behind the lunch was to showcase some older wines and to listen to winemakers talk about how the region has evolved over the last 25 years. We started with Quartz Reef 2000 which Rudi had disgorged the previous day and which was perfect; complex, autolytic but with elegance and restraint.
Rob Hay spoke about the earliest pioneers, Grant Taylor focussed on the three biggest changes during the mid 90s (an exploration of sub-regionality, the advent of contract winemaking and the genesis of a region working together to promote itself), Roger Gibson on the role of the viticulturist, Dean Shaw on the evolution of winemaking techniques and the move to screwcaps and finally Claire Mulholland and Sarah-Kate Dineen on the future.

After yet another wonderful lunch, the low key, informal setting seemed to promote discussion and conversation at our table ranged from the arrival of big names such as Cloudy Bay Vineyards into the region, whether natural wines were the way to go, how much whole bunch is enough and, most importantly, who would wear the most outlandish outfit to the Feraud Dinner.
1989 Chard Farm Riesling
1997 Black Ridge Pinot Noir
1996 Gibbston Reserve Pinot Noir
2002 Felton Road Chardonnay
2002 Peregrine Pinot Noir
2002 Carrick Pinot Noir
2003 Pinot Noir Celebration Pinot Noir
2008 Lowburn Ferry Pinot Noir
2008 Two Paddocks Pinot Noir
2009 Burn Cottage Pinot Noir
2009 Maude Pinot Noir
2009 Sato Pinot Noir
Central Otago – New Release tasting
A horridly turbulent flight to Queenstown and a stomach rolling journey over the Crown Range meant I arrived at Rippon Vineyards feeling a tad queasy. But after a cup of coffee and a historic date scone, I felt mega perky. And the view from the tasting room made the journey worthwhile.
I had been invited to Central to attend the 25th Anniversary Celebrations and my first day was spent tasting through 75 Central Otago pinots, all blind, roughly split between the 2010 and 2011 vintages.
And though the 2010 may be regarded as the ‘better’ vintage, I found the 2011s to be perhaps more to my taste. Lighter coloured, with fruits in the red spectrum; raspberry, strawberry and cherry, refreshing acidity and silky, low impact tannins, most of the wines were pretty, floral and delicious. Perhaps not for the long haul, but then how many people want to cellar wines these days?
Before I left Auckland I had a conversation with a pinot producer who thought Central Otago should have won more gold medals at the Spiegelau Wine Competition. I looked back at my judging notes I saw I had used words such as brutal, tough and charmless on several wines, not just from Central. Tannin is no bad thing in pinot but perhaps should play a supporting role in wines from younger vines yet too many times wines were over extracted, with heavy handed oak swamping the fruit and none of the charm for which pinot is famed.
My faith was restored by many of the 2011s. Of course there were a couple of slightly grisly wines, but that’s to be expected in any region.
In the evening we were hosted by Wooing Tree Winery who had flown Cuisine Magazine’s 2012 Chef of the Year Brenton Low in from Whangarei to prepare a delicious dinner. Aided by a couple of trainee chefs from the local Cromwell Polytechnic, the food was a great showcase for the local wines. A perfect end to the first day.
Barcelona
I didn’t manage to get back to Shropshire to celebrate my Mum’s 70th birthday back in August. So instead, I delayed my return to Auckland by a couple of days and we spent a great weekend Barcelona.
We visited all the usual tourist places, argued whether Gaudi’s unfinished masterpiece was indeed stunning or butt ugly, took an open topped bus tour to see as much of the city as possible and ate one supper outside in the Placa Real square, watching a Catalan version of AC/DC (I had to text my Mum throughout the meal as conversation was impossible).
Although the city is full of museums, cathedrals and stunning architecture, in the end, we decided La Boqueria market was our favourite.
London – Day One
It must be 20 years since I went to a football match and almost the same length of time since I last drank Chateau Grillet. Last night, I broke the drought, went to Selhurst Park to see Crystal Palace play Nottingham Forest and had a glass of the about to be released 2009 Grillet before the game. I caught the train from London Bridge and hadn’t realised the Shard now towers over the station.
Older vintages of Grillet have often been a bit ‘hit and miss’, with good bottles overshadowed by those that had prematurely aged or that looked a bit flabby and hot. But the 2009 was really delicious. Quite tight on the nose (perhaps could have done with a decant) but the palate was rich and textural. Subtle and not at all blowsy despite carrying 14% alcohol. Thanks to Tom Ashworth of Yapp Brothers for sharing.
2012 Spiegelau International Wine Competition
I’m in Blenheim this week to judge the Spiegelau International Wine Show and last night Competition Director Belinda organised a wine options game. Each team was made up of one judge, one associate judge and two stewards which gave everyone the opportunity to meet those who do all the back room work. Raymond Chan hosted the game and chose :
2011 Te Mata Cape Crest Sauvignon Blanc
2010 Classic Vouvray Bredif
2008 Taylors Jaraman Chardonnay
2007 Isole e Olena Chianti Classico
2007 Mt Edward Pinot Noir
2009 Seghesio Zinfandel
I was part of a great team (Sarah, Sarina, Kate). We knew the other teams would be tough opponents but the girls dug deep, didn’t underestimate the opposition and stuck to our game plan. Despite a woeful round 4 (the Chianti was a bit miserable) we tied for first place with Team One and it came down to a tiebreaker question. The alcohol level on wine 6? We opted for 15.25%, Team One for 15.45%.
We won and were rewarded with a bottle of sparkling wine.
Sunday Star Times column #113
Though I have a habit of putting my foot in it, I couldn’t have predicted the word ‘liquorice’ would have provoked such an extreme reaction.
In Shanghai to judge the new international Wine 100 competition, I was explaining to my fellow judges, all Chinese wine professionals, that a certain wine had an aroma of liquorice. The judges looked perplexed so I asked Fongyee Walker, who lives in Beijing but was brought up in England, for some help.
After some discussion in Mandarin, everyone looked horrified.
“No-one understands why you’ve used that word” said Fongyee. “The Chinese regard liquorice as a medicine and there is no way they’d think of it as a positive descriptor for wine”.
Tasting notes written by NZ producers and wine writers, me included, often feature a host of fruits, flowers and plants that are common to us but unfamiliar to the Chinese. For example several had tasted raspberries but most weren’t familiar with blueberries. As for liquorice? That was a definite no-no.
Instead what seemed of utmost importance to the Chinese judges was texture. When we went out for dinner, the dishes were chosen as much for the texture as for the taste and contrasting slippery, crunchy and spicy foods all played a part. When judging white wines, those with complex mouthfeel were scored more highly. Oak aged NZ sauvignon blanc, a marginal category here, was held in much greater esteem than the more popular typical Marlborough styles.
My role, as chair of one of the tasting panels was to mentor the judges, many of whom were trained sommeliers. I showed them how to assess large numbers of wines and although they hadn’t had much experience of the ‘western’ way of judging, all were highly skilled. Many had formal wine education qualifications and all were passionate to learn more. The New Zealand wine industry sees China as a market with great potential. Perhaps to capitalise on the opportunity producers should spend as much time listening to these new consumers as they do promoting their own wines. And of course, remove any reference to ‘liquorice’ in their marketing material.
Fast Fact : According to Fongyee Walker, the Chinese adore gewurztraminer because the flavours of honey, ginger and lychee are familiar to them.
2011 Mahi Sauvignon Blanc 4.5 stars
This is exactly the style of wine that appealed to the judges. Not showy, but with fantastic texture and complexity. A silken, dry sauvignon blanc, its layers of citrus and mineral flavour interwoven with nutty subtle oak.
2010 Pegasus Bay Gewurztraminer 4.5 stars
This is a tremendous wine; highly scented, hugely fleshy, densely fruited and generously flavoured. It is a luxuriant cuddly style of wine with masses of texture and appeal. Just off dry, it is drinking perfectly now.
Shanghai
I’ve spent the last few days in Shanghai judging a brand new wine competition, Wine 100 and I’ll post my thoughts on the competition and the NZ wine masterclass I hosted tomorrow. Having never been to Shanghai before I found it an exhilarating city that operates at a tremendous pace. The contrast between old and new is marked; elegant colonial buildings and modern skyscrapers, luxury imported cars and roads full of cyclists, and everything blanketed in a gentle haze of pollution.
Now on my way home, I only wish I could have spent longer there.
Sunday Star Times column #112
When Chris Scott, winemaker at the Church Road Winery, asked if anyone had heard of marzemino, I was tempted to reply that I thought one had just won Crufts.
But I decided not to be flippant. We had just been told that a ghostly figure sometimes appears in the barrel hall and although I don’t believe in the paranormal, I wasn’t taken any chances.
I was in Hawke’s Bay to taste the Church Road ‘Tom McDonald’ wines, a range that pays tribute to the man who started working at the winery as a young man and later went on to buy the property. Scott explained the new range replaces the Cuve series, that despite often containing some gems, suffered from an uninspriring name and label design.
The Tom McDonald series of eight wines is almost exclusively from the group of French varieties upon which this winery, and Hawkes Bay in general, have made their name. But I wonder what McDonald would have made of the marzemino, a grape variety native to northern Italy, that has produced an intensely coloured red with a sour cherry and cranberry character and retains an unmistakeable savoury Mediterranean edge. Perhaps he’d like the more traditional Merlot, an intense gutsy wine with plenty of charm.
Scott isn’t the only winemaker who has been busy launching a brand new wine this month.
Waipara’s Black Estate was established back in 1993 but since it was taken over by winemaker Nicholas Brown and his wife Penelope Naish in 2007, it has gone from strength to strength. I’ve been very impressed by all the releases to date but the brand new 2010 Omihi Pinot Noir is the best yet. This single vineyard pinot noir has oodles of a character I find in Waipara pinots but which I have up until now struggled to define. Tasting this wine I realised that it is redcurrant jelly (a personal favourite) with an intense red fruit note, never overripe, yet with a sweetness and plumpness too.
Although only small in terms of volume and with only 20-odd wineries, Waipara has more than its fair share of talented winemakers. A quiet achiever and a region to watch.
Fast Fact : The Church Road Winery houses a small wine museum, open to the public, with tours running twice a day. A fascinating collection of wine artifacts from both here and overseas.
2010 Black Estate Omihi Pinot Noir 5 stars $45.00
This intensely fragrant single vineyard pinot has a delightful redcurrant jelly and raspberry character. A savoury edge gives structure and balances the dense, fleshy fruit. Attractive now yet better in a couple of years.
2009 Church Road Tom McDonald Pinot Gris 5 stars $32.99
Inspired by the late harvest wines of Alsace, Scott has crafted a medium dry pinot gris that is powerful yet pure. Amazing concentration and length, this would be perfect with roast pork belly, fresh chilli and ginger.












